Did the Phoenicians Discover America? - Thomas C. Johnston




III. Navigation and Sea Trade

Extent of the Phoenician marine—Causes of its remarkable development—Nature of early voyages—Phoenician policy non-aggressive —First Phoenician colonial settlements—The ships of Tharshish—Their testimony to Phoenician seamanship—Trade monopoly in the Eastern Mediterranean—Also I in the Atlantic—Xenophon's description of a Phoenician armed merchant-ship—Phoenicians preeminent as shipbuilders and navigators.

Stupendous as the land operations of the Phoenicians were they were as nothing compared with their sea trade, with which indeed their chief fame will always be identified. To the beginnings of this sea trade we have already referred in dealing with the causes which led to the selection of the Bahrein Islands as a centre from which to control the Arabico-Babylonian trade.

Subject as their emporia on the lower waters of the Euphrates were to the periodic raids of the predatory tribes that swept over the Mesopotamian plains from the north, and harassed in their business operations by the conflicting interests of the great monarchies that grew up in Babylonia, the Phoenicians found very early that not only travel but trade could be conducted more securely and cheaply by sea than by land. In so doing they solved the one great problem of commerce and became the foremost intermediaries of the ancient world.

The centres of trade and manufacture at that period were mainly confined to Babylonia, Arabia, India, and Egypt, and as these countries were separated from one another by immense deserts or stretches of sea, whoever was in a position to control the carrying trade between them and the outlying territories was necessarily mistress of the commerce of the ancient world, and had the right to dictate on practically her own terms the rate of exchange on such commodities as were handled. The astute and enterprising sons of Canaan seized the opportunity thus presented, and in a short time became factors of the first importance in distributing to the outskirts of the known world the products and manufactures of the more favoured and densely populated regions as well as those riper fruits of civilisation that blossomed in the centres of wealth, culture, and refinement. Thus they brought within the range of their influence practically every centre of population, civilised and uncivilised, known to the ancient world.

During the historic period the navigation of the seas was confined to the Persian and Arabian Gulfs, the Indian Ocean as far as Ceylon, and the coasts of the Deccan. There is good reason for believing that it may even have reached the mouth of the Ganges. Some doubt has been expressed as to the practicability of voyages to the more distant of these regions at an early period, but this doubt seems scarcely reasonable when we admit the existence of a Red Sea navigation (i Kings ix. 27) of the most extensive character in the eleventh century B.C.

There were, moreover, various circumstances which contributed to the development of this navigation, for none of the voyages need have been more than mere coasting expeditions, the straits of Ormus at the mouth of the Persian Gulf and those of Babelmandeb at the entrance to the Red Sea reducing the distance from Arabia to India and from Arabia to Ethiopia to a negligible quantity. Again, the directions of the periodic monsoons in the Indian Ocean, which are very similar to those prevailing in the Persian and Arabian Gulfs, were peculiarly favourable to voyages made to and from India and Ceylon, the Arabian Peninsula and the Ethiopian mainland.

Once embarked on this business, even in a small way, the advantages of sea over land transportation, in respect to the territory which was thereby made tributary to the establishments of the Phoenicians, would, apart from all other considerations, have provided a sufficient justification for its adoption as a certain means of securing that monopoly in trade on which their profits depended. And this the more so that the provinces of Hydramaut and Yemen, in which were situated the great central marts for the gold, precious stones, spices, and frankincense of Arabia, the rich products of India and Ceylon, and the equally valuable merchandise of Ethiopia, were easily reached by means of mere coasting voyages over a comparatively smooth sea, whereas the land journey, as we have shown, was through an inhospitable desert.

If, however, a controlling interest in the produce of the Indian and Arabian markets was the magnet which drew the Phoenicians to the Bahrein Islands, and there can be little doubt that it was, it is quite certain that they did not long rest satisfied with the commercial leverage which they obtained over the Persian Gulf. There is very clear evidence that their navigation was not confined to these waters, but at a very early period embraced the southern boundaries of the Arabian Peninsula, and probably extended to the borders of Egypt. Theophrastus in his $$History of Plants##, when speaking of the frankincense trade, mentions the port of Hierapolis, the present Suez, as much used in connection with this business. The magnitude of the transactions of the Phoenicians in the southern markets must have placed them in a peculiarly favourable position for securing such shipping and warehouse facilities in the ports of Hydramaut and Yemen as the exigencies of their business demanded. If, therefore, the Phoenician trade between Yemen and Egypt cannot from positive historic testimony be affirmed, it can at least be reasonably enough assumed. With the route and the value of the trade the Phoenicians seem to have been familiar from the beginning, so much so that they lost no time in making overtures to the Jews for the transference to their own control of the two ports of Eloth and Eziongeber on the Aelantic Gulf, when the practical extermination of the Edomites provided an opening for a more complete control of the Ophir trade (i Chron. xviii. 12, 1 Kings ix. 27).

The reason for the development of the Red Sea navigation can be easily understood. The Egyptian markets could only be supplied with the products of Ophir, either by direct communication with the southern emporia by caravan or ship, or through Gerrha and the Phoenician headquarters on the Persian Gulf. The advantage of sea transport from Yemen was, however, so apparent that, as we have seen, it led to the transference of the Phoenician headquarters to the Bahrein Islands. As a means of controlling the Egyptian markets it would have been as effective as in the case of the Babylonian, so that it is unnecessary to suppose any other reason than a desire to facilitate this trade with the south Arabian ports in order to understand the easy and continuous access which the Phoenicians enjoyed to the port of Hierapolis, and, in all probability, to those of Yemen and Hydramaut.

There can be no doubt that it was the recognition of the strategic importance of the Bahrein Islands as a central emporium for the great markets of the ancient world that led the Phoenicians to establish their first settlements there. This view is not dependent on a recognition of the nature and origin of the architectural remains found there, but receives the strongest possible confirmative support in the fact that all the early trade routes which honeycombed the Arabian Peninsula, routes which have undergone no change, always found their outlet at the Bay of Gerrha, opposite to the site of Phoenicia's first warehouses. The erection of the early Phoenician emporia on the Bahrein Islands was, therefore, an act of rare sagacity. It placed the Phoenicians in an unrivalled position to divert into such channels as the exigencies of their commercial enterprises might demand, not only the produce tributary to the Persian Gulf, but equally that which found its natural outlet at the Red Sea. That a trade existed between Yemen and Egypt there can be no question (Asiat. Res., vol. iii. p. 324).

It is more than probable that it extended to the Persian Gulf ports at an early period, because at a later date it was shared in by the Chaldasans. Moreover, the mere fact that the Phoenicians seized the opportunity presented by their political and commercial affiliations with the Jews to secure a port under their own control on the Red Sea in place of one under foreign espionage, seems to indicate that they were already familiar with the navigation, which again implies that they were to some extent at least in possession of the trade, and were desirous of further developing it.

It will, moreover, be seen that the ports of the Phoenicians at Tylos and Arados were admirably situated for handling by sea the trade of Arabia and India with Babylonia, and that of Babylonia with India and Arabia, at a tithe of the expense which such journeys would have entailed by caravan transport. The position placed them in an equally advantageous position with respect to the Egyptian trade. This view provides an adequate explanation of the early navigating skill of the inhabitants of the Arabian Peninsula, and of their possessing in connection with this navigation, as we shall have occasion to show later, the bactellium or loadstone which only could have come to them through Phoenician sources.

The trade with the Arabian Peninsula must likewise have been greatly facilitated by reason of the similarity of the languages of the two peoples (Heeren, p. 360), for they were of the same Semitic stock. Even in later times the language of Phoenicia and of Arabia were so similar that they could be described as two dialects of the same speech. This advantage alone would have been sufficient to have secured them a predominant influence in the commerce of Arabia, even if the situation of their emporia and their possession of the sea transport had not rendered it practically impossible for any other nation to compete with them.

It is only in this way that it is possible to come to an intelligent understanding of the opening chapter of the first book of Herodotus, where is indicated the existence of a considerable trade on the part of the Phoenicians with the Assyrian and Egyptian markets. Nor is this familiarity with these markets surprising, because the population of the Nile valley, as has been shown, was for at least six centuries part and parcel of Phoenician civilisation, being either the mainstay of the Hyksos invasion or those driven to the eastern shores of the Persian Gulf. The civilisation of Egypt was, moreover, one of the most ancient, and as it had always enjoyed the principal river and land traffic of Africa it would have been passing strange if no intercourse had existed between two such distinctively commercial peoples as the traders of the Bahrein Islands and the Egyptians. Indeed it is only by assuming the existence of such a trade at a very early period that we can understand how it came about that after the expulsion of the Hyksos and the doors of Egypt were double barred against the entrance of all foreigners, especially Semitics, the Phoenicians were permitted to retain their residence in the old Hyksos capital at Memphis.

From the beginning it must have been apparent to the Egyptians that the territorial aggrandisement was no part of the policy of the Phoenicians, who established themselves within their boundaries and brought to their doors the products of Babylonia and the wealth of Ophir, as well as relieved them of the surplus products of their cotton and linen looms, and those masterpieces of art, the embroideries of cotton on cotton, which were so highly valued throughout the ancient world. If, however, the naval emporia at the Bahrein Islands were in the beginning the key to the Babylonian, Arabian, and Egyptian trade, it is clear that there must have come a time when the success of the traders of Tylus and Arados in controlling these markets must have created a spirit of irritation in both Egypt and Babylonia, probably even among the carrying tribes of Arabia. To what extent business rivalry may have influenced the removal of the Phoenicians to the Mediterranean and their beginning there a new career as a manufacturing as well as a commercial nation cannot be determined. All the probabilities, however, are in favour of the view that if it affected the movement it was only in a minor degree. But there were more important influences at work calculated to produce this result, namely, the discovery on the one hand of the unrivalled dye to be obtained from the purple-producing murex on the Syrian coasts, and on the other the discovery of the Eldorado in the silver mines of Spain, the tin mines of England, and probably the amber of the Baltic.

It is unnecessary to suppose that any political upheaval operated to bring about the change of base for the Phoenician establishments. Ordinary business prudence would have dictated such a policy, more especially as the increasing competition of the carrying tribes in the southern markets must have made it apparent that the trade between Yemen and India with Babylonia could not much longer remain a monopoly in their hands, whereas in the new territory, as the only navigating people of the ancient world, they had it in their power to block in the most effective manner any attempt on the part of their eastern competitors to secure a participation in the western trade. Moreover, the west at this period was not what it had been at the beginning of the Phoenician career, simply Egypt or the Syrian coasts, for these migratory movements from the further east had covered the islands and shores of the inland seas with settlements which, in many cases, had grown into populous communities, thus offering the widest scope for the mercantile proclivities of the traders of the Bahrein Islands.

It requires no special sagacity, therefore, to recognise the causes which led to the change of base, and at the same time to the remarkable developments in Phoenician naval construction and navigation. On the Syrian coast the durable cedars of Lebanon were substituted for the teaks of the Persian Gulf, and the placid waters of the eastern seas were exchanged for the turbulent and stormy waters that washed the shores of the Mediterranean.

It is true that we have no historic record showing the stage to which the Phoenicians carried their navigation either on the Persian Gulf or the Red Sea further than can be drawn from our knowledge of their trade with India, Arabia, and Egypt. If, however, we even confine it to these seas and read the story in the light of their exploits immediately on their arrival on the Mediterranean, it will be apparent that both shipbuilding and seamanship must, in their hands, have passed far beyond the primitive stages before they left the Bahrein Islands. Otherwise the statement of Herodotus that, immediately on their arrival on the Mediterranean, they forthwith applied themselves to such distant navigation as that of the Argolic coasts would be wholly incomprehensible. This statement is too precise to leave any room for doubt as to the meaning which Herodotus intended to convey, for Nauplia, which was always the main port on the Argolic coast, was distant as the crow flies some 700 miles from the Phoenician coasts, and could only be reached by navigating the Levant, whose gales at certain seasons are as much dreaded as any that blow.

These early voyages on the Mediterranean were in no sense coasting voyages, nor were they conducted by novices in the art, but by seasoned and experienced seamen. It is curious that this fact should so far have escaped the observation of all writers on the subject of Phoenician navigation, for Herodotus, in his account of this memorable voyage to the Argolic coast, says distinctly that after the completion of their business "they immediately set sail for Egypt." Now, as Egypt lay 800 miles due south of Argos, a coasting voyage was plainly out of the question.

Whether the entire transference of the early navigators from the Persian Gulf to the Syrian seaboard occupied a few years or a few centuries cannot be stated, but at all events it led to great developments in Phoenician naval construction and navigation. During no portion of their career could the navigation from the Persian Gulf have reached beyond 30 north or south of the equator. For even if at this point we admit, with a view to clarifying the situation, the possibility of an American discovery, certainly all of the region occupied by the early civilised states of Central America lay between these latitudes, and during the season of navigation was well defined to the ancients by the rise and setting of the Pleiades, which the Phoenicians were the first people to put to a practical use.

The situation of the new home of the Phoenicians on the Mediterranean placed them abreast of problems in navigation of a very different character from those with which they had been accustomed to wrestle on the Persian Gulf. The real perplexities of navigation only begin when 35 north or south latitude have been reached, and the major portion of the Mediterranean, including Asia Minor, Greece, Sicily, Italy, North Africa, Spain, the Levantine and Adriatic seas, the Straits of Hercules, and the major portion of the Atlantic in which the main trend of their commerce lay, was beyond these latitudes, so that all the skill the shipbuilders, navigators, and scientists of Phoenicia possessed must have been called into play.

Here, therefore, on the shores of this sea of "the setting sun," in this virgin territory, where transportation was largely reduced to terms of their own choosing, where from its very situation they were for centuries protected from competition, the Phoenicians secured a complete monopoly of the Mediterranean and Atlantic trade and became a "merchant of the people for many isles" (Ezek. xxvii. 3). At the beginning of the thirteenth century B.C. a great commercial and navigating nation, capable and aggressive beyond all others, occupied the Phoenician coasts. For many centuries it was the good fortune of these pioneers to enjoy an entire monopoly of the trade. But scarcely fifty years had passed after the close of the Trojan war before the Greek tribes, owing to the influx of a mixed population from the north, were thrown into violent confusion. This resulted in the displacement of large masses of population, who, spreading themselves over the adjacent coasts and islands, so increased the boundaries of Greece that it soon came to embrace many of those choice and delightful districts of the eastern Mediterranean that from a high antiquity had been colonised by the Phoenicians.

As a commercial people it was, as has been pointed out, a fixed policy of the Phoenicians to avoid as far as possible all occasions of friction with the various peoples with whom they established business relations. Accordingly, when towards the beginning of the eleventh century B.C. the jealousy of the Pelasgic states, which had been steadily growing in importance, threatened to precipitate conflict, the Phoenicians ceded voluntarily many favoured regions which for long had remained within the sphere of their influence. This policy was rendered easier of accomplishment in that prior to this date they had already pushed into the western Mediterranean, and ere long the tin mines of the Cassiterides and Britain and the fossilised resin or amber of the Baltic were to become important factors in Phoenician commerce.

With rare good judgment, therefore, the Phoenicians transferred their activities to a region where they enjoyed a complete monopoly in place of disputing for merely sentimental reasons the possession of a territory where profits would necessarily have been rendered precarious by competition. Moreover, under any circumstance the Greeks would still be forced to purchase in the markets of Tyre and Sidon those goods of finer grade which could not be obtained elsewhere.

The coasts of the Mediterranean most celebrated for the murex fishing were, as we have shown, those of Phoenicia, Asia Minor, the Peloponnesus, and Sicily. Only less valuable, however, were the fisheries on the western Mediterranean and on the Atlantic coasts, Britain, and in all probability the modern Madeira.

There can be no doubt that it was the shell-fish producing this invaluable dye that, in the first instance, led to the amazing developments that took place in naval construction and the spread of the Phoenician colonial system. The whole fish was not used in the preparation of the dye, but an almost microscopic quantity obtained from a small sac at the back of the head, which is said to have yielded only one drop, whereas three hundred pounds of the dye, according to some authorities, were required to dye fifty pounds of wool. From this it will be seen that the home fisheries could not for any long period have yielded an inexhaustible supply of the precious fluid. Consequently the fishermen found it necessary to go farther afield, where, although not so rich in the finer shades of colour, still provided a fluid of great commercial value.

That the first colonial settlements of the Phoenicians were therefore of the nature of mere fishing stations will easily be understood, for nearly all the Mediterranean colonies were in the first place identified with this industry. The name purple, however, must not be understood as representing one distinct colour, but the entire range of colours obtained from the murex, of which nine were simple purple colours from white to black, and five mixed (Heeren, Phoenicia, p. 343). As, however, the quality and colour of the dye was determined by physical causes superinduced by the temperature of the sea, sunlight, and the food on which the murex subsisted, an enormous area was necessarily brought under levy to provide suitable pigment for the wide range of colours demanded by the world-wide trade to which the dye-vats of Tyre and Sidon catered.

In a consideration of the causes which led to the phenomenal development of the Phoenician marine, it is necessary that we should not lose sight of the increasing range of these voyages, for in this will be found a sufficient cause not only for the increasing tonnage of the Phoenician ships, but also for the spread of their colonial system as a means of providing harbours to which their vessels might run in case of emergency (Asiat. Res., vol. i. 318). It should also be remembered that the size of the vessels of the Phoenicians would not depend on their fitness to carry the relatively small cargo of a manufactured nature consigned on the outward voyage, so much as on their carrying capacity for the bulky raw material which formed the staple of the return cargoes.

Probably it is in consequence of the insufficient attention that has been given to this aspect of the subject that there has been a disposition to belittle the advanced state of the Phoenician marine during the period of Hiram and Solomon. This is unfortunate, because it has prevented a true estimate of the progress of the nation, both with respect to the extent of its colonial developments and the growth of its marine. If we conceive of it as represented by types of such craft as are outlined on Phoenician coins and tombs during the period of Phoenicia's greatest expansion, it will clearly be impossible to suppose that the nation was ever employed on such voyages as those that will shortly engage our attention.

Until 500 B.C. no Greek ship had penetrated beyond the pillars of Hercules. Phoenicia was at that time the only navigating power in the world. We may therefore conclude that "the ship of Tharshish" had attained its final developments before 1050 B.C., and was then a permanent portion of the Phoenician marine, for the foundation of Gades as the terminal point of the Mediterranean and the starting-point for the Atlantic trade had already become of considerable importance. If, therefore, any reliance can be placed on the American Votanic tradition of the arrival on the Pacific coasts of that continent of seven large ships about the year 1000 B.C., it will clearly be necessary for us to turn to this only navigating nation of antiquity for information on the subject, for, as we have already shown, there was no other nation of the ancient world who, either by reason of the state of their marine or familiarity with the southern and eastern Asiatic seas, was capable of making the journey.

Voyages across the open sea are not, as has so often been erroneously stated, the outcome of our acquaintance with the new world from the Atlantic ports, but are the natural result of the evolution of the nautical art and the discovery or invention of the loadstone. So long as navigation was confined to coasting or even stretching from headland to headland along the coast line, very little progress was possible. Once this method of navigation was discarded and steering by a stellar object took its place (which was clearly of Phoenician origin), supplemented by the use of the magnet, which enabled the navigator when the weather was cloudy to determine his position and direction (also, it is equally clear, a Phoenician invention), then the last obstacle to a complete mastery of the sea was removed.

The history of the compass and its evolution from the bactellium or loadstone stage is therefore necessarily involved in the elucidation of our enigma. As, however, it is too complex a subject to be dealt with briefly in connection with navigation, it will be profitable to treat it separately. But we may be pardoned if, at this point, we content ourselves by saying that there is strong evidence to show that the instrument was of Phoenician origin.

It is undoubtedly true that the historic voyages of the Phoenicians were mainly over a fixed course. But besides these they were in the habit of fitting out expeditions for purposes of discovery, which, as we have shown, often led to an enlargement of their commerce, though sometimes they seem to have had no result beyond the mere extension of geographical knowledge. In one of these voyages, undertaken during the early part of their career, when they set out to explore Europe, they discovered not only the Isle of Thasos but its gold-mines, which for centuries yielded them an immense revenue.

In spite of these historic facts, however, many writers of high repute have not hesitated to question the possibilities of a greater eastern navigation than that of the Red Sea and the Persian Gulf, and even to call in question the trustworthiness of the narrative of Herodotus, who ascribes to the Phoenicians the distinction of being the first people to circumnavigate Africa (Her. iv. 41). But as our investigation hinges more particularly on the evolution of "the ship of Tharshish" than on any other portion of the Phoenician marine, we will confine our attention to this phase of our subject for a little.

The name Tharshish, as we have shown, was not first applied to one of the districts of the Spanish Peninsula, but derived from one of the sons of Javan, who reached southern Italy, where he and his descendants settled. The name indeed only became displaced as the horizon of the Phoenician navigators moved westward. The name Tharshish, therefore, even when Phoenicia was at the zenith of its power, seems to the Hebrew writers expecially to have represented only a certain region by which the Mediterranean was bounded on the west, just as to Europeans the West Indies for centuries meant not only the islands which we now call by that name, but the whole continent of America, both north and south, with the islands that cluster around them.

The vessels, which went by the name of ships of Tharshish, and were employed on these long voyages to Italy and the Adriatic, and, later, to Cadiz and the Atlantic ports, were so called to distinguish them from the smaller craft plying on the eastern Mediterranean. The Tharshish ship, therefore, must be viewed as having been evolved pari passu with the extension of Tharshish westward, so that probably it stood for the terminal point of the Mediterranean voyages, when a steady trade between the Spanish Peninsula was in operation. There can be no reasonable doubt as to the Tharshish ship having formed the model after which the Greeks constructed their great Alexandria corn ships, which were famous during the early portion of the Christian era (Acts xxvii. 6). We have no difficulty, therefore, in recognising the class of vessel to which the Tharshish ship was allied, and it would be imprudent to associate it with the sculptured reliefs of the Sargonid period in which the Phoenician galleys are represented.

We should naturally expect that the evolution of these ships of Tharshish would have been all the more regular and certain by reason of the centuries occupied in their development, the increasing range of their navigation, and their better acquaintance with the peculiar difficulties that beset their course on the western Mediterranean. From Tyre or Sidon to the Argolic coast, or rather to Nauplia, which was always the leading port, was a distance of 700 miles as the crow flies, but the distance from Tyre to Gades was 2500 miles. The tin islands were, however, 1200 miles from Cadiz, and the shores of Norway 2000 miles from the Spanish port, so that if the tin and amber of these distant regions were with the silver of the Iberian Peninsula pouring at that time into the warehouses of Tyre and Sidon, it is easy to understand the causes that were at work in the final developments of the Phoenician marine. The navigation of 900 miles, which the journey from Tyre to the Baltic implies, and this through many degrees of stormy north latitude where steady trade winds and the tideless Mediterranean could not be counted on, must have taxed to the utmost the skill and resource not only of the hardy seamen of Phoenicia, but even of the wise men of Tyre, who, it would seem from the remarks of the prophet Ezekiel (xxvii. 8), were, on account of the arduous nature of some of these voyages, called to the assistance of the State in the protection of its monopolies. It should also be apparent from the nature and extent of Phoenician navigation that their voyages were prosecuted by night as well as by day, even if we had no direct testimony that they were accustomed to steer by the pole star (Ency. Brit., xviii. 804). We also know from Herodotus (iii. 136) that they made charts of those seas in which they did business, and from the remarks of Strabo (xvi. 757) that they used arithmetical calculation for reckoning the ship's progress at night and the relative position of ports, which leads us to suppose that they were in possession of some instrument like the log for determining the speed of their ships. Besides they were not only familiar with spring and neap tides but with their causes.

From a consideration of these facts there should be no great difficulty in realising that the Phoenicians had passed far beyond the primitive stages of seamanship and navigation long before the twelfth century B.C. By reason of their knowledge and practical ability they were entitled to make the proud boast that no navigation was impossible to them.

The needs of an uncivilised, or at best only partially civilised, people are necessarily of a somewhat rudimentary character, so that the outlying settlements opened up by the increasing range of these voyages must have proved extremely valuable to the Phoenicians as a market for their gew-gaws and trinkets, and even more for the disposal of those surplus stocks of manufactured goods no longer in demand in the more civilised centres where custom and fashion gave pattern and design only a temporary value.

The mere fact that the main trend of the business of the Phoenicians was always toward the great centres of civilisation, makes it apparent that it was not only on account of the quality of their goods but equally on account of their manner of disposing of them that they were highly approved. There is, nevertheless, just as little doubt that while the transactions of the larger merchants in the great centres of population such as Babylonia, Yemen, Greece, and Egypt earned for the Phoenicians a reputation for probity and trustworthiness, the commerce of the outlying regions and the more sparsely populated territories opened up by the increasing radius of their navigation was largely in the hands of bold and often unscrupulous ad venturers. Still it is difficult to conceive of business being continued on such lines much beyond the incipient stages, especially on the coasts of Asia Minor and the Greek Archipelago, for these regions were at an early period colonised by their own people, who carried with them the leavening influence of a somewhat advanced civilisation. It is, therefore, more than probable that after a few generations the traders with the main centres of civilisation must have recognised that a continuously profitable business could only be conducted by a practical application of the belief that honesty was the best policy.

The magnitude of the Phoenician transactions in the Babylonian, Egyptian, and Arabian markets, in consequence of the position which they occupied as a manufacturing and exporting as well as an importing nation, must have enabled them for centuries to enjoy a complete monopoly of the trade of the eastern Mediterranean. During the period from 1500 B.C., when Cadmus, the son of Agenor, king of Phoenicia, first arrived in Boeotia, carrying with him the sixteen letters of the Phoenician alphabet, until at least 1100 B.C., when the Greeks took possession, the eastern end of the Mediterranean, or at least that portion which includes the Sporades and Cyclades, Cyprus, Rhodes, the Peloponnesus, and the coasts of Asia Minor generally, was colonised by the Phoenicians and wholly occupied by their marine. Here they catered to the inhabitants with articles of the most costly description, for which there was always a steadily growing demand. Among these were the products of Southern Arabia, the manufactures of Tyre, the purple garments and rich apparel so much in demand among the priestly and wealthy classes, the jewellery of gold and amber, priceless silver ornaments and bronzes, and those trinkets and gewgaws for which the Phoenician workmen had always been famous. With whatever good grace the Phoenicians may have accepted their dismissal from the markets nearest to the home ports, they speedily adopted a policy with regard to their more distant settlements that seems to have stood the nation in good stead. Henceforth they allowed nothing to transpire either with regard to their navigation to these distant settlements or the character of their colonial expansion. Probably it was this policy of secrecy that was instrumental in the rapid progress of Phoenicia as a manufacturing and navigating nation, for they could not have failed to recognise that it was only to these distant settlements that large consignments of merchandise could be made, the sales in all other markets being of a more or less retail character.

The need of protecting their colonial expansion from invasion by outsiders demanded at the same time the ability to supply all the distant markets required, and that with as good if not a superior character of merchandise to that obtainable elsewhere. Moreover, as this traffic was one of barter pure and simple, Phoenicia was necessarily the final arbiter of values, the ultimate profit to the merchant not depending wholly on the purchasing price of the merchandise that was carried abroad, but on the value of the raw products in the home markets.

There was one branch of their distant sea trade io which the Phoenicians clung with extreme tenacity, and which at a date long subsequent to the seventh century they prevented even the Romans from sharing with them. This was the tin trade with the Scilly Isles and the coasts of Cornwall, which was one of the chief sources of their wealth, tin being required by nearly all the races with which they had dealings, for hardening into bronze the copper which they used for tools.

Throughout their long career the Phoenicians pre-eminently distinguished themselves in the working of mines. So great was the quantity of silver found by the Phoenicians on their first arrival in the south-western portion of the Spanish Peninsula, that they are said to have loaded their craft with the metal down to the water's edge and, on returning to Tyre, to have so fired the imagination of the nation with their tales of the wealth of this western Eldorado as to cause many of their countrymen to proceed to Spain, which was rich not only in metals but also in corn, wine, oil, wax, wool, and fruits. Thus the sea trade to this distant region became of the most advantageous character to the Phoenicians at a time when they were losing their hold on the more convenient markets of Asia Minor and the Peloponnesus.

Another advantage accruing to the Phoenicians from the Spanish colonies was the service which they rendered in the extension of their commerce on the Atlantic, for Gades was not only the port for the Tharshish trade but likewise the starting point for a more extended navigation on the Atlantic coasts. The great value of the tin, silver, and amber derived from this further west by the Phoenicians explains quite satisfactorily the care they exercised that they should not be supplanted in these regions as they had been nearer home. Amber in the Mediterranean markets was as valuable as gold, while silver in the southern countries was even more precious than that metal. Tin was also extremely valuable.

Relatively small vessels have in all ages been considered the most suitable for purposes of exploration and discovery, because many dangers are avoided by the use of vessels of light draft. It would be unwise, therefore, to judge of the possibility of discovery in any region of the world by the Phoenicians by simple reference to the size of the vessels in their possession at any given period. Rather should we view the comparatively small craft which they employed on these expeditions, when well equipped and commanded by the right men, as representing a type of vessel that was thought to be the most effective. Indeed, the mere fact that the small craft of Columbus and Cook fulfilled the expectations of the practical seamen who selected them should not be lost sight of in an inquiry such as this, for the question of the original discovery of America by Igh and Imox (Nat. Races, v. 164) is necessarily involved, and this must have taken place some years before the construction of these ships of Tharshish for Solomon and Hiram.

The ship of Tharshish was evolved by combining in one vessel the peculiar features belonging to the round merchant Gaulos and the long lost ship of war. It was the starting-point for the creation of an entirely new type of vessel, which in its main features has survived through succeeding ages, although it does not seem to have become a fixed model before the twelfth century B.C., when the Tharshish trade as relating to the Spanish Peninsula assumed vast dimensions. History has not left us in complete ignorance regarding this phase of Phoenician naval architecture. By reference to Xenophon (Oecon., viii. 11) we obtain a rather graphic account of a Phoenician armed merchant ship of this type during the Persian period, which is usually placed about 500 B.C. In this passage Xenophon makes one of his characters say,

"I think that one of the best and most perfect arrangements of things that I ever saw was when I went to look at the great Phoenician sailing vessels, for I saw there the largest amount of naval tacking separately disposed in the smallest stowage. For a ship, as you know, is brought to anchor and again got under weigh by means of a number of wooden implements and of ropes, and sails the seas by means of a quantity of rigging, and is armed with a number of contrivances against hostile vessels, and carries about with it a supply of weapons for the crew, and has besides all the utensils that a man keeps in his dwelling for each of the messes. In addition it is loaded with a quantity of merchandise which the owner carries with him for his own profit. Now all these things which I have mentioned lay in a space not much larger than a room which could conveniently hold ten beds. And I remarked that they lay in such a way as not to obstruct one another so as to consume time when they were suddenly wanted for use. Also I found that the captain's assistant, who is called the look-out man, so well acquainted with the position of all the articles and with the number of them that even at a distance he could tell where everything lay and how many there were of each, just as one who had learned to read could tell the number of letters in the name of Socrates, and the proper place for each. Moreover, I saw this man in his leisure moments examining and testing everything that the vessel needed when at sea. Sons, I was surprised, I asked him what he was about, whereupon he replied, 'Stranger, I am looking to see in case anything should happen how everything is arranged and whether anything is wanting or is inconveniently placed, for when a storm arises at sea it is not possible to look for what is wanting or to put to rights what is awkwardly arranged.'"

It should be clear from this description that the navigation of the Phoenicians was neither of the primitive character nor conducted in the reckless manner that some writers have attributed to it, for the apparent purpose of Xenophon is to call attention to the fact that the Phoenician ships were a class by themselves and vastly superior to those of his countrymen. That many of the Phoenician vessels, especially those employed on the Syrian seaboard, were small enough to haul on shore there can be no question, but that many of the vessels were of respectable size and that monster ships, even for modern times, were by no means uncommon, is apparent. The ship in which St. Paul was wrecked carried 276 persons beside her crew and a cargo of wheat (Acts xxvii. 27). Josephus again tells of his being wrecked in the Adriatic in a vessel which carried 600 passengers. These vessels have by competent authorities been computed to have measured from 600 to 1000 tons burthen.

There is at the same time abundant reason for believing that the seamanship of the ancients and the sailing powers of their vessels were far advanced. It may be safely conceded that they did not sail so close to the wind as our more modern ships, but they could get within seven points, which shows that they were not so dependent on a fair wind as has generally been supposed. The rate at which the vessels sailed was likewise considerable. St. Luke and St. Paul, with a fair wind, made the run from Rhegium to Puteoli (Acts xxviii. 13), a distance of 182 miles, in a day, which gives an average of from seven to eight knots an hour, a rate much superior to the five knot average on the 140 day run over the 15,000 mile course from California to Europe made by grain ships to-day.

The point we seek to emphasize, however, is not that the Phoenicians were in possession of monster ships with great sailing powers, but that they were capable of building and sailing any ships that the exigencies of their private business or the business of the State demanded; that their navigation was over long courses and was conducted with prudence, foresight, and skill, and furthermore, that both the ships and the nautical skill requisite to the discovery of America from the Red Sea port of Eziongeber were in their possession long before the period of Hiram and Solomon.

Indeed it is futile to attempt to intelligently understand the state of the Phoenician marine either at the Solomonic or any other period by comparison with that of other nations of the ancient world. As ship-builders and navigators the Phoenicians were in a class by themselves. So isolated was their position that for 2100 years, or from 611 B.C., when Phoenician seamen circumnavigated Africa, the world was confronted by a feat which, so far as we know, was not repeated until the fifteenth century of our era, when Vasco da Gama revolutionised the commerce of the world by doubling the Cape of Good Hope from the west. To arrive at the advanced position which we occupy with respect to the nautical arts, we have been compelled to relay the foundations on which the Phoenicians reared their marvellous creations. The more closely we examine the ruins of the Phoenician marine the more we are impressed by the presence of a knowledge which served the needs of those adventurous pioneers for a thousand years. "Are we indeed," asks Heeren, "in a position to judge even with a tolerable degree of accuracy of the perfection to which Phoenician navigation was carried or of its various resources? The long centuries during which they were exclusive masters of the sea gave them sufficient time in which to make that gradual progress which was perhaps all the more regular in proportion to the time which it occupied. They carried the nautical art to the highest point of perfection then required, and gave a much wider scope to their discoveries and enterprises than either the Venetians or Genoese, their numerous fleets being scattered over the Indian and Atlantic Oceans, the Tyrian pennant waving at the same time on the coasts of Britain and Ceylon." {Hist. Res., iii. 340).